Saturday, July 27, 2024

RUNNING AWAY

   Henry Miller:

   "Everything we shut our eyes to, everything we run away from, everything we deny, denigrate, or despise, serves to defeat us in the end. What seems nasty, painful, evil, can become a source of beauty, joy, and strength, if faced with an open mind. Every moment is a golden one for him who has the vision to recognize it."


   ERWIN ROUSSELLE. A CHINESE TALE:

   “The Chinese - and in this he has remained true to his heritage of age-old wisdom - has never forgotten the fearful aspect of everything that is truly great, and in tales and legends the magnificent primordial monster rises again and again to his consciousness. There is, for example, the story of the dragon-like spirit of Stallion Mountain:

   A peasant has dallied at the market and is a little tipsy as he starts on his ride homeward. As he approaches the ridge of Stallion Mountain, he suddenly sees a monster sitting by the brook, lapping up water. Its enormous face is blue; its eyes bulge out of its head like those of a crab. Its mouth gapes from ear to ear and has the aspect of a vat full of blood. Its fangs, growing in irregular clumps, are two or three inches long. The peasant is terrified, but the monster does not look up. Profiting by this, the peasant starts on a wide detour around the terrible ridge.

   As he rounds a bend, he meets the son of a neighbor, who calls to him. The peasant tells him briefly that he has just seen the monster nearby, and the neighbor’s son asks leave to ride with him. The peasant, eager to carry him as fast as possible from this awful place, lets him mount behind him. As they are riding along, the neighbor’s son asks him in a crafty voice: "What exactly did the monster look like?" The peasant feels ill at ease and replies beseechingly: "I'll tell you everything when we get home." But the other persists and says: "Turn around; perhaps I look like the monster." A cold shiver runs through the peasant and he cries out: "Don't make evil jokes. A man is not a spirit." But the other jeers and repeats: "Turn around." The peasant refuses and the other pulls him around by the arm. And the peasant looks into the face of the monster and falls unconscious from his saddle.”

   Thus suddenly, beneath the mask of everyday, the mask of the neighbor’s son, the horror which lies at the primal source of being - the monster by the stream - suddenly confronts man. He tries to escape but cannot. He carries the monster with him; it attacks him from behind, and in the dread of recognition man loses his senses, falls headlong into the depths.”   [1]


TWO QUOTES FROM  PEMA CHODRON:

      “Trying to run away is never the answer to being a fully human being. Running away from the immediacy of your experience is like preferring death to life.”

   "If we run a hundred miles an hour to the other end of the continent in order to get away from the obstacle, we find the very same problem waiting for us when we arrive."  


NOTE

[1] From: Erwin Rousselle, Dragon and Mare - Figures of Primordial Chinese Mythology, [1934] Papers from the Eranos Yearbooks.: Eranos 6. The Mystic Vision, Edited by Joseph Campbell, p. 107.

 

 

 

Monday, July 8, 2024

THE CHURCH OF LIGHT

 

FROM:

Robert S. Ellwood, Jr., Religious and Spiritual Groups in Modern America, Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, N.J., 1973), pp. 183 – 185

6. The Church of Light

   The Church of Light is a body whose main focus is astrology. This ancient art has always been a substantial part of the occult tradition, although it has generally been an adjunct intellectual sport or tool of the wise whose major concern is expansion of consciousness. Yet it is not unrelated, for its symbols can also be taken as symbols of the Return. Its study can be a means of attaining tranquillity and balance of consciousness, as well as a means of utilizing the powers of the psyche or cosmos in the quest. In the case of the Church of Light, the astrological part of the alternative reality tradition has been made the key to the whole although it teaches other related aspects of it, such as Tarot, and affirms its basic impersonal monism and soul-body dualism.

   The founder was Elbert Benjamine (1882-1951), who wrote under the name C. C. Zain. In the last years of the nineteenth century he devoted himself to occult studies, developing his psychic abilities, and in the year 1900, he said he contacted an arcane order called The Brotherhood of Light. This order, it is said, separated itself from the Egyptian priesthood in 2440 B.C. From then on it survived as the custodian of the Religion of the Stars. The Greek philosophers Thales, Pythagoras, Plato, and others were initiated into it, and it has preserved learning even in the darkest times. In some periods its membership has for the most part been on the “Inner Plane,” but it has also had its representatives, if not its highest leadership, in the physical world. Benjamine studied for nine years under its tutelage, and then in 1909 took a mysterious journey during which he was inducted as a member of a council of three which manages its affairs in this world. He was also given instructions to prepare a course of study, a complete system of occult learning, so that the Religion of the Stars could be made more available in the coming Aquarian Age. In 1915 Benjamine came to Los Angeles where he began teaching and working on the instruction, which was finally completed in 1934. The instruction is comprised of 210 lessons, published in twenty-two substantial books.

   The replication of the magus archetype in this life story is evident, and is borne out by the descriptions of his character in the group's literature. He was a man of warm, emotional kindness, yet “few people ever saw him as he really was”; he had to protect himself against those who wished to attract his attention for selfish reasons; his method of teaching could be enigmatic, for he would not solve people’s problems for them; and he had sometimes to work on a cosmic scale. In 1932, the Church of Light was founded. At times it suffered adversity, although recently, owing to the general upsurge of interest in astrology, it has prospered mightily. In addition to the Church in Los Angeles, it has contact persons and in some cases study groups in many cities around the world.

   The Church of Light’s official statements of principles tend not to mention astrology, but to talk of the evolution of the soul, from man to angel or spirit. In a manner reminiscent of A. J. Davis, reincarnation is denied, but it is held that the soul passes through higher and higher levels in the transmundane cosmos. The compatibility of the teachings with science, and the fact they are not to be received just upon authority, is stressed. Spokesmen seem particularly avid to repudiate orthodoxy. Yet it is clear that members are most interested in the Church’s astrological teachings. Its bookstore sells largely astrological books, its symbolism is primarily astrological, and at least half of Benjamine’s twenty-two lesson books treat astrology. It seems that it is the keystone of his occult system, as the Aquarian Age concept is of its timing.

  This is explained as being because the law of correspondences, which is central to Neoplatonism and the alternate reality tradition, provides the main dynamic for the soul’s evolution and the laws which govern it. Everything in human life has its correspondence to a Zodiacal sign or planet. The stars provide a language by which life can be read. The Tarot, which occupy second place in the Church of Light’s symbolism, is another way of saying the same things. Understanding astrology can enable one to employ “mental alchemy,” to turn negative influences in one’s life to good by mentally strengthening the power of its opposite. If there is too much Mars, Venus is the answer. Astrology provides a sense of the total cosmic and psychic environment in which man can learn to gain this sort of power and to grow. The stars are man’s funda-mental Bible, or Word of God, for instruction and encouragement.

  The Church of Light has fifty degrees of initiation, culminating in the Soul Degree in which one must demonstrate there has been specific realization of higher states of consciousness. The work of the fiftieth degree is imparted secretly to a member when he is ready.

  The major exoteric work of the Church of Light is the classes, mostly general instruction in astrology open to the public. Religious services are held only once a month, at three on a Sunday afternoon. They are quite simple. There is an opening and closing ritual of saying the “Church of Light Mantram” with arms upraised, a statement of principles, two or three talks, and a healing meditation. Members are also supposed to do the Mantram daily at noon. The membership is mostly middle-aged, and consists predominantly of women of middle-class background. As many as half are widows, divorced, or single. All, even the young people, seem very conventional in dress and manner. The Church makes it known that they encourage only serious students, those interested in spiritual development, not just fortune-telling or fads.

 

Reading Selection: The Church of Light

 

   The following few paragraphs are from the lesson series written by C. C. Zain, and reflect his sober tone and continuing efforts to build bridges between the ancient science of astrology and the modern world.

The Stellarian religion is called The Religion of the Stars because astrology affords the best possible road-map for guidance to the most effective and highest type of life. It not only gives the most reliable instructions as to what he should do to live his religion, but it also instructs him how best he can do the things which his religion indicates he should do.

   If astrology and other inner-plane conditions are so important in religion, and if knowledge of them when applied will increase the individual’s success, happiness, spirituality and freedom from illness 100%, why do so many academic intellects refuse to consider or investigate them?

   With time, distance and gravitation on the inner plane having properties so radically different than they have on earth, should we expect inner-plane weather to operate according to the same laws weather operates on earth? Einstein’s Special Theory of Relativity carried to its logical conclusion indicates that inner-plane weather affects the individual, not merely according to his inner constitution, but through certain time-space relationships. These time-space relationships that indicate the inner-plane weather affecting the individual are measured by progressed aspects.

   Just how the inner-plane weather affects an individual, however, is not dependent upon any theory. For even as time, distance and gravitation properties on the inner plane have been determined experimentally by university scientists, so have the properties of inner-plane weather, and how it works to affect individuals, groups, cities, nations and world affairs been determined experimentally through statistical studies carried out in the process of astrological research.

 

C. C. Zain (Elbert Benjamine), Astrology is Religion’s Road Map (Los Angeles: The Church of Light, 1949), pp. 229-31.

Wednesday, September 6, 2023

TAROT CARDS

CARDS

Cards function in the religious context both as instruments for performing divination rituals and as repositories of esoteric sacred teaching. Current historical evidence suggests that cards originated in China and that their sacred usage developed from shamanistic or Taoist divinatory rituals that predated cards themselves. The oldest extant card, found in Chinese Turkistan, dates from no later than the eleventh century. The design of Chinese cards was copied from paper money first used in the Tang dynasty (618–908 CE). The design of an arrow on the back of the oldest Korean cards suggests that those cards developed from a divination technique for interpreting the pattern of arrows randomly cast onto a circle divided into quadrants.

   Number and pattern, and their orderly transformations, are in sacred mathematics symbolic expressions, or hierophanies, of the eternal divine essences and processes that manifest themselves to us in time as the visible cosmos. The pack of divination cards is a homologue of the set of divine mathematical potentialities that can manifest itself in the time and space of the cosmos. The spontaneous play of the cards, like in any other particular act of divination, reveals a meaningful structure homologous to the divine creative process, which manifests itself within worldly events. The interpretation, or reading, of any particular play of cards is essentially a matter of intuiting from the sacred mathematical symbolism of the cards the worldly events whose structure corresponds to that symbolism.

   It is not certain when and where cards first appeared in Europe. One hypothesis is that they were brought into southern Europe by the Moors as early as the eighth century. The earliest mention of numbered cards is in Covelluzzo’s Istoria della citta di Viterbo (1480). Covelluzzo says that they were brought to the city of Viterbo by the Saracens in 1379.

    In her extensive study A History of Playing Cards (New York, 1966), Catherine P. Hargrave says that these early numbered cards were probably European copies of Chinese cards that arrived through Venice. The oldest extant European cards are several tarot cards from a pack designed for Charles VI of France in 1392.

   The two most prominent packs of cards used in Europe for divination are the ordinary pack, consisting of fifty-two cards, and the tarot pack, consisting of seventy-eight cards. The ordinary pack is divided into four suits—diamonds, clubs, hearts, and spades. Joseph Campbell (in Campbell and Roberts, 1979) has suggested that the four suits represent the four estates, or classes, of the medieval social order: clergy (hearts), knights (spades), merchants (diamonds), and peasants (clubs). The four suits of the ordinary pack possibly developed under Protestant influence from the earlier tarot suits of chalices, swords, coins, and staves. The fact that the four suits of the ordinary pack culminate in the figures of knave, queen, and king leads Campbell to suppose that the pictorial symbolism of the cards expresses a medieval esoteric initiatory tradition wherein ascent along any of the four lines represented by the suits leads to spiritual realizations of equivalent value and importance.

   The tarot pack falls into two sections: the “minor arcana” of fifty-six cards, divided equally into four suits, and the “major arcana” of twenty-one numbered picture cards and one unnumbered card, the Fool. The origin of the tarot deck is not known. The first history of the tarot, Le jeu des tarots (Paris, 1781), was written by Court de Gebelin. Gebelin claims that the deck originated in ancient Egypt and represents the esoteric teaching of the god Thoth, recorded and expressed in a hieroglyphic alphabet, in which all the gods are symbolized by pictorial signs and numbers. While Gebelin’s theory of Egyptian origins is clearly itself of a mythic nature (the Rosetta Stone, which made translation of hieroglyphics possible, was not discovered until 1790), the evidence of recent research on the history of symbols indicates that the deck is indeed, as Gebelin supposed, a repository of sacred teaching and esoteric knowledge. The pictorial symbolism of the deck is known to have much in common with the symbolism of spiritual initiation rites and instruction in Hellenistic mystery cults, ancient astrology, and medieval alchemy, wherein the processes of manifesting divine energies are represented in the progression of visual and numerical symbols.

BIBLIOGRAPHY

   Tarot Revelations by Joseph Campbell and Richard Roberts (San Anselmo, Calif., 1979) is a detailed work summarizing the phenomenological evidence linking the tarot to Hellenistic religion and alchemy as well as the tarot’s place in nineteenth- century esoteric societies.

   New Sources

   Baird, Merrily. “Card Games.” In her Symbols of Japan: Thematic Motifs in Art and Design. New York, 2001.

   Giles, Cynthia. The Tarot: History, Mystery, and Lore. 1992; reprint. New York, 1994.

   Preston, Cathy Lynn and Michael Preston. “Catholic Holy Cards: Visual, Verbal, and Tactile Codes for the (In)visible.” In their The Other Print Tradition: Essays on Chapbooks, Broadsides, and Related Ephemera, pp. 266–283. New York, 1994.

   Richard W. Thurn, Cards, Encyclopaedia of Religion, Vol. 3, 1987, pp. 1412 - 1414

 

 

 

Monday, July 10, 2023

ECOPSYCHOLOGY

Theodore Roszak:

   “Most of the world's mystic and occult traditions have been worked up from the gnosis of primitive and pagan cultures. At bottom, these traditions are sophisticated, speculative adaptations of the old folk religions, which preserve in some form their antique wisdom and modes of experience. Behind the Cabbala and Hermeticism, we can still see the shadowy forms of ritual magic and fertility rites, symbols of a sacred continuum binding man to nature and prescribing value. In all these mystic traditions, to know the real is to know the good, the beautiful, and the sacred at the same time.”

   Theodore Roszak, The Monster and the Titan: Science, Knowledge, and Gnosis, Daedalus, Vol. 103, No. 3, Science and Its Public: The Changing Relationship (Summer, 1974), pp. 17-32 .


Where Psyche Meets Gaia", in Roszak, Theodore, Mary E. Gomes, and Allen D. Kanner, ed. Ecopsychology: Restoring the Earth, Healing the Mind. San Francisco, CA: Sierra Club Books, 1995. [ONLINE HERE]


Spirituality in the Work of Theodore Roszak: Implications for Contemporary Ecopsychology, Tristan L. Snell, Janette G. Simmonds, and R. Scott Webster, [Faculty of Education, Monash University, Clayton, Australia. Faculty of Arts and Education, Deakin University, Burwood, Australia.]

ABSTRACT

“Despite the recent flourishing of ecopsychology research, risks may be involved if ecopsychology remains a loosely defined paradigm. We suggest that drawing from some of the central themes of Theodore Roszak’s The Voice of the Earth (1992), a seminal text of ecopsychology, may help to elucidate the unique contribution of ecopsychology and its sustained relevance for environmentally focused psychologies. To provide a comprehensive review, we consider The Voice of the Earth by placing this text in the context of Roszak’s broader body of literature, discussing his earlier and more recent works. We particularly focus on the theme of spiritual experience throughout Roszak’s literature, as we believe that this is one of the more unique and important aspects of his work that has implications for the future development of ecopsychology as a paradigm and social movement. In conclusion, we suggest that Roszak’s emphasis on the value of a spiritual or animistic experience of nature, as a means of fostering empathy toward the natural world, may assist in providing meaningful focus to contemporary ecopsychology.”  [ONLINE HERE]

Saturday, April 1, 2023

CREATIVITY IN CHAOS

   The most exquisite carved Chinese jades were created during a period of great chaos in Chinese history. Even when a house is burning down, we wave a blanket. Creativity continued in the Concentration Camps. Though I make my bed in Hell, &c. The process of reconstruction begins from the centre of destruction. It is not that we ignore the pressing issues of the day. We have to concentrate on the Causes, and not the Effects. And who is to decide what the Causes are? Especially when a misinformation campaign of industrial proportions keeps the Causes from being Revealed?  An inspiring view is given by Karl Paulnack:

“One of the most profound musical compositions of all time is the Quartet for the End of Time written by French composer Olivier Messiaen in 1940. Messiaen was 31 years old when France entered the war against Nazi Germany. He was captured by the Germans in June of 1940, sent across Germany in a cattle car and imprisoned in a concentration camp.

   He was fortunate to find a sympathetic prison guard who gave him paper and a place to compose. There were three other musicians in the camp, a cellist, a violinist, and a clarinetist, and Messiaen wrote his quartet with these specific players in mind. It was performed in January 1941 for four thousand prisoners and guards in the prison camp. Today it is one of the most famous masterworks in the repertoire.

    Given what we have since learned about life in the concentration camps, why would anyone in his right mind waste time and energy writing or playing music? There was barely enough energy on a good day to find food and water, to avoid a beating, to stay warm, to escape torture­ why would anyone bother with music? And yet­ from the camps, we have poetry, we have music, we have visual art; it wasn’t just this one fanatic Messiaen; many, many people created art. Why? Well, in a place where people are only focused on survival, on the bare necessities, the obvious conclusion is that art must be, somehow, essential for life. The camps were without money, without hope, without commerce, without recreation, without basic respect, but they were not without art. Art is part of survival; art is part of the human spirit, an unquenchable expression of who we are. Art is one of the ways in which we say, “I am alive, and my life has meaning.” 

   From a welcome address given to the parents of entering freshmen at the Boston Conservatory, given by Karl Paulnack, pianist and director of the Music Division. 

Monday, January 2, 2023

TERENCE MCKENNA

 

Dennis McKenna, Brotherhood of the Screaming Abyss: My Life with Terence McKenna, North Star Press of St. Cloud, 2012

For those who lived through what is sometimes called the Psychedelic Revolution, Terrence McKenna is a legend. Once referred to as "the intellectual's Timothy Leary." Terence attained iconic status as a radical philosopher, futurist, cultural critic, and raconteur. His unorthodox ideas about the evolutionary and cultural impact of psychedelic drugs shocked many and resonated with many others. In 1971, we embarked on an expedition to the Amazon, bent on uncovering the real mystery behind psychedelic experience. Terrence died in 2000, never to learn if his predictions about the end of the world, in his particular sense, were true. As Terence's younger brother and only sibling, I grew up with him in a small town in western Colorado during the fifties and sixties. Traveling together in the Colombian Amazon in 1971 with a few other kindred spirits we called our band "the Brotherhood of the Screaming Abyss." As Terence's brother, I helped him create and develop many of "his" ideas. Terence became the spokesman for the alien dimensions accessed through psychedelics, a philosopher of the unspeakable, a beloved and sometimes reviled bard of the marvels and occasional terrors waiting in the recesses of human consciousness. By choice and inclination, I stayed in the background, pursuing a scientific career in disciplines that ranges from ethnopharmachology and ethnobotany to neuroscience. Since Terence's death, we've witnessed the first decade of a new era that by all early indications will be as strange and disturbing, as full of hope and despair, as any period that humanity has yet endured. I've been drawn to look back at how our personal world began. I wanted to retrace the journey that took us from our childhood to our separate destinies, stopping to revisit the people and ideas that shaped us


Charles Hayes, Terence McKenna, Tripping: An Anthology of True-Life Psychedelic Adventures, Penguin Compass, 2000

Taking a balanced, objective approach, the book depicts a broad spectrum of altered states, from the sublime to the terrifying. Included are fifty narratives about unforgettable psychedelic experiences from an international array of subjects representing all walks of life. Supplemental essays provide a synopsis of the history and culture of psychedelics and a discussion of the kinetics of tripping.


Rupert Sheldrake, Terence McKenna, Ralph Abraham, Chaos, Creativity, and Cosmic Consciousness, Park Street Press,  2001

Three of the most original thinkers of our time explore issues that call into question our current views of reality, morality, and the nature of life. A wide-ranging investigation of the ecology of inner and outer space, the role of chaos theory in the dynamics of human creation, and the rediscovery of traditional wisdom. In this book of "trialogues," the late psychedelic visionary and shamanologist Terence McKenna, acclaimed biologist and originator of the morphogenetic fields theory Rupert Sheldrake, and mathematician and chaos theory scientist Ralph Abraham explore the relationships between chaos and creativity and their connection to cosmic consciousness. Their observations call into question our current views of reality, morality, and the nature of life in the universe. The authors challenge the reader to the deepest levels of thought with wide-ranging investigations of the ecology of inner and outer space, the role of chaos in the dynamics of human creation, and the resacralization of the world. Among the provocative questions the authors raise are: Is Armageddon a self-fulfilling prophecy? Are we humans the imaginers or the imagined? Are the eternal laws of nature still evolving? What is the connection between physical light and the light of consciousness?

Part ceremony, part old-fashioned intellectual discussion, these trialogues are an invitation to a new understanding of what Jean Houston calls "the dreamscapes of our everyday waking life."


McKenna, Terence, Food Of The Gods: the Search for the Original Tree of Knowledge, Ebury Publishing, 2010

A journey is some of the Earth's most endangered people in the remote Upper Amazon. . . . a look at the rituals of the Bwiti cults of Gabon and Zaire. . . . . a field watch on the easting habits of 'stoned' apes and chimpanzees - these adventures are all a part of ethnobotanis t Terence McKenna's extraordinary quest to discover the fruit of the Tree of Knowledge. He wonders why, as a species, we are so fascinated by altered states of consciousness. Can you reveal something about our origins as human beings and our place in nature? As an odyssey of mind, body and spirit, Food of the Gods is one of the most fascinating and suprising histories of consciousness ever written And as a daring work of scholarship and exploration, it offers an inspiring vision for individual fulfilment and a humane basis for our interaction which each other and with the natural world. 'Brilliant, provocative, opinionated, poetic and inspiring. . . . . Essential reading for anyone who ever wondered why...


Rupert Sheldrake; Terence McKenna, The Evolutionary Mind: Conversations on Science, Imagination & Spirit, Monkfish Book Publishing, 2013

Stimulating and often startling discussions between three friends, all highly original thinkers: Rupert Sheldrake, controversial biologist, Terence McKenna , psychedelic visionary, and Ralph Abraham , chaos mathematician. Their passion is to break out of paradigms that retard our evolution and to explore new possibilities. Through challenge and synergy they venture where few have gone before, leading their readers on an exciting journey of discovery. Their discussions focus on the evolution of the mind, the role of psychedelics, skepticism, the psychic powers of animals, the structure of time, the life of the heavens, the nature of God, and transformations of consciousness.


Terence McKenna, Dennis McKenna, The Invisible Landscape: Mind, Hallucinogens, and the I Ching, HarperOne, 1994

A thoroughly revised edition of the much-sought-after early work by Terence and Dennis McKenna that looks at shamanism, altered states of consciousness, and the organic unity of the King Wen sequence of the I Ching.

Monday, June 6, 2022

THE MERITORIOUS FROG

KASHYAPA is considered by Tibetan Buddhists to be the third in the series of earthly Buddhas, the one who appeared before Buddha Shakyamuni, the 'historical' Buddha.

One day, during a public teaching, the mellifluous voice of this fully-enlightened being rang out to the hills where a herder who was tending his flock happened to hear it.  He could not catch every word but he was so taken by the sound, that he stopped where he was to listen.  Resting his chin upon his hands that were planted palm down atop it, he fell under the spell of the sound of the Buddha's voice.

Now, deep in the ground just below where the staff was planted was a frog holed up for the cold weather.  It was just his misfortune that the stockman's staff pierced his body as the vibrations of the Buddha's teaching resonated down the shaft of wood and reached him.  But the little frog did not struggle, nor make any sound, for he was filled with joy at hearing the dharma and did not want to cause a disturbance. 

When the teaching came to an end, the shepherd moved on with his flock and the frog quietly and serenely  expired.  Because of his virtuous decision not to interrupt the sounds of dharma, the frog was reborn in the Realm of the Gods.  This little frog became chief among them, Lord Indra, himself.

This Jataka (Buddha's life tale) as retold by Karma Kagyu Khenpo Chokey Gyaltsen of Pullahari, Nepal, emphasizes how merit is gained even in dire circumstances, for the Dharma helps transform our attitude which influences our actions perhaps eventually leading to our Liberation.

http://www.khandro.net/animal_frogs.htm

 Jin Chan: Wikipedia

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jin_Chan

Friday, May 27, 2022

HYMAN BLOOM

 

“Hyman Bloom was once prominent enough to be dubbed the “first Abstract Expressionist artist” by Willem de Kooning and Jackson Pollock. The artist, who was raised as an Orthodox Jew, fell out of the limelight for a variety of reasons. Not least of these was his involvement with spiritual concerns.

His paintings present jewel-like surfaces that are engulfed by a struggle between light and darkness. The work is indebted to a moment of mystical illumination he experienced as a young man during a period of extreme isolation and financial hardship. As he described it, “I had a conviction of immortality, of being part of something permanent and ever-changing, of metamorphosis as the nature of being.”

His recent show at the Museum of Fine Arts Boston, “Matters of Life and Death,” is centered on his paintings of cadavers, which, along with lushly painted near abstract representations of synagogues, rabbis, chandeliers, seances, and archaeological digs, were part of his exploration of the astral plane. This concept posits a state of being that exists between life and death and is informed by Bloom’s deep reading of theosophical texts, as well as his interest in mysticism, kabbalah, and other esoteric religions”

Hyman Bloom, [American, 1913–2009] Cadaver on Table, 1953, oil on canvas, 52 x 40 in. (132 x 102 cm) Henry Melville Fuller Fund, 2018.

https://currier.org/collection/hyman-bloom/

Eleanor Heartney, Spirituality Has Long Been Erased From Art History. Here’s Why It’s Having a Resurgence Today, ArtNet News, January 6, 2020.

https://news.artnet.com/art-world/spirituality-and-art-resurgence-1737117

Thursday, February 17, 2022

SYMBOLISM OF BIRDS

 

BIRDS are primarily the epiphanies of the gods and spirits, but they also appear as messengers of the heavenly divine beings. They announce new situations in advance and serve as guides. Moreover, birds symbolize man’s soul or spirit as it is released from the body in ecstasy or in death; the bird is a symbol of absolute freedom and transcendence of the soul

from the body, of the spiritual from the earthly. Hence, a bird is often associated with divinity, immortality, power, victory, and royalty.

   Birds and bird-masked figures are clearly attested as early as the Palaeolithic period. In the cave painting at Lascaux in the Dordogne, dating from approximately 15,000 BCE, a bird-masked person is depicted as falling backward before a bison confronting him. At his feet lies his spear-thrower, and the spear that he has discharged has pierced the bison’s body. Quite close to them is a bird perched on a pole. Most scholars interpret this scene as depicting a hunting tragedy: wearing a bird mask, the hunter has been killed by the bison. The mask may have been used as a device to enable the hunter to approach his prey without being noticed. The bird on a pole may represent the soul of the dead man or the totem and mythical ancestor of the tribe to which he belongs. For other scholars, the scene presents the shamanic trance. The man wearing a bird mask is a shaman; he lies unconscious while his soul has departed for the ecstatic journey to the world beyond. A companion on this spiritual journey is his helping spirit, here symbolized by the bird on a pole. The bison is possibly a sacrificial animal.

Although it is still uncertain whether shamanism originated in the Palaeolithic period, birds undoubtedly occupy a very important place in the spiritual world of hunters generally and of northern Eurasia in particular, where shamanism has been a dominant magico-religious force. In fact, the shaman of Inner Asia and Siberia receives help from the spirits of wild animals and birds when undertaking an ecstatic journey.

   Bird spirits (especially those of geese, eagles, owls, and crows) descend from heaven and enter the shaman’s body to inspire him as he beats his drum, wearing the shamanic costume of the bird type. Otherwise, they move into his drum or sit on his shamanic costume. This is precisely when shamanic ecstasy occurs; the shaman is transformed into a spiritual being, a bird in his inner experience. He moves, sings, and flies like a bird; his soul leaves the body and rises toward the heavens, accompanied by bird spirits. This motif of the ascending bird spirit has been revalorized by Daoism on a new spiritual plane: in the Zhuangzi, dating from the third century BCE, for example, a huge bird named Peng appears as the symbol of the soaring spirit that enjoys absolute freedom and is emancipated from mundane values and concerns. When a shaman dies among the Yakuts, the Tunguz, and the Dolgans, it is customary to erect on his tomb poles or sticks with a wooden bird at each tip. The bird symbolizes the soul of the departed shaman.

  Birds appear in the myths of creation that centre on the theme of the cosmogonic dive or the earth diver. In the beginning, when only the waters exist, aquatic birds (ducks, swans, geese, or swallows) dive to the bottom of the primeval ocean to fetch a particle of soil. Birds dive sometimes by God’s order and sometimes by their own initiative, but in some variants God transforms himself into a bird and dives. This motif of the diving bird, common among such Altaic peoples as the Buriats and the Yakuts, is also found among the Russians and such Uralic peoples as the Samoyeds, the Mansi, the Yenisei, and the Mari. Earth divers also appear in a certain number of Indian cosmogonic myths of North America. The result of the courageous dive is always the same: a small particle of soil that has been brought up grows miraculously until it becomes the world as it is today. In Finnish and Estonian cosmogonic myths, God flies down as a bird onto the primeval ocean and lays on it the cosmic eggs from which the world emerges. This motif is also found in Indonesia and Polynesia.

   Myths of kingship in northern Eurasia are often imbued with the symbolism of birds. According to the Mongolians, a golden-winged eagle gave them the yasa, or basic rules of life on the steppes, and helped them to establish the foundation of the Mongol empire by installing Chinggis Khan on the royal throne. Japanese myths tell how a crow (or raven) and a golden kite flew down as messengers of the heavenly gods and served Jimmu, the first mythical emperor of Japan, as guides in his march through the mountains to Yamato, where he established his imperial dynasty. The Hungarians have the tradition that the Magyars were guided by a giant turul (falcon, eagle, or hawk) into the land where Árpád founded the Hungarian nation. The turul is known as the mythical ancestor of the Árpáds.

   These myths of creation and kingship reveal the prominent role played by birds in the formation of the cosmic order. As an epiphany of a god, demiurge, or mythical ancestor, a bird appears in the beginning of the world, and its appearance serves as an announcement of the creation of the universe, of the alteration of the cosmic structure, or of the founding of a people, a dynasty, or a nation. The eagle in Siberia, as well as the raven and thunderbird in North America, is especially invested with the features of the culture hero.

   Often described as the creator of the world, the bird is the divine being who familiarizes the people with knowledge and techniques, endows them with important cultural inventions, and presents them with the rules of life and social institutions. In the ancient Near East and the Greco-Mediterranean world, birds are charged with a complex of symbolic meanings. Here, as elsewhere, the bird is essentially an epiphany of deity. In the Near East the dove usually symbolizes the goddess of fertility by whatever name she is known, and in Greece it is especially an epiphany of Aphrodite, the goddess of love. The eagle is a manifestation of the solar deity, as is clearly illustrated by the winged sun disks of Mesopotamia and later of Persia. The eagle is often represented as engaged in fighting with the snake or dragon. This archaic motif, attested in the Near East, India, and the southern Pacific, shows the tension that exists between the celestial solar principle and that of the maternal chthonic forces, but it also reveals man’s inextinguishable aspiration for universal oneness or wholeness, which can be achieved by the cooperation and synthesis of conflicting powers.

  The bird, and particularly the dove, often symbolizes love as an attribute of the goddess of fertility. In the cults of Dumuzi and Adonis, the goddess appears as a mother who laments over her son’s captivity in the underworld and descends there to rescue him, to raise him from the dead. It is possible that the dove’s moaning contributed to making it the special symbol of the goddess of love in the ancient Near East. In Greece the dove is an epiphany of divinity, but divinity in its amorous aspect, as can be seen from the dove’s association with Aphrodite. In the Greco-Mediterranean world the dove has never lost this erotic connotation. The eagle, the king of birds, is inseparably associated with royalty as well as with the solar deity. Indeed, royalty has never severed its symbolic ties with the sun and the eagle. In the Near East certain coins depict Hellenistic kings wearing a tiara with a pair of eagles on it facing the sun between them. In utilizing these symbols, the kings declare that they are divine by nature or deified. The divinity of the Roman emperor is expressed through the symbolism of Sol Invictus (“the invincible sun”) and the eagle.

   More generally, birds in the ancient Near East also signify the immortal souls of the dead. This celebrated image seems to have survived in Islam, where it is believed that the souls of the dead will remain as birds until the Day of Judgment. In Greece, images of the dove on graves may symbolize the soul of the departed, the divinity coming to help the departed, or the soul now in divine form. In Syria, the eagle depicted on tombs is the psychopomp, who leads the soul of the deceased to heaven. On Egyptian tombs the soul of the dead is represented as an androcephalic bird. However, soul birds (hawks, ducks, or geese) in Egypt have more than one function, usually in connection with the mummy. Certainly they are immortal souls, but they also symbolize divine presence and protection; birds bring all sorts of nourishment to the corpse to revive it. Thus in Egypt as elsewhere, the bird is both the soul of the departed and the divinity, regardless of what bird is depicted. The peacock, which in the Greco-Roman world may have symbolized man’s hope for immortality, is of Indian origin. In Buddhism not only the peacock but also the owl and many other birds appear as epiphanies of the Buddhas and bodhisattvas, preaching the message of enlightenment and compassion. The bodhisattva Mayurasana, for example, is usually portrayed riding on a peacock.

   In Judaism the dove and the eagle, the two most important birds, seem to have kept much the same symbolic values intact although they have been given specific Jewish colourings. The dove depicted on Jewish tombstones, in the wall paintings of Jewish catacombs, and on the ceilings of synagogues signifies Israel the beloved of God, the individual Israelite, or the salvation and immortality given to the faithful by God. In rabbinic tradition, too, the dove symbolizes not only the soul departing at death, but especially Israel the beloved. Moreover, the dove serves as the psychopomp. The eagle is equally multivalent; it is an epiphany of God of the power of God, but it is symbolic also of man’s hope for eternal life and immortality.

   The Christian symbolism of the dove and the eagle has also undergone a process of revalorization. The dove signifies the Holy Spirit in the baptism of Jesus, but is also becomes the erotic and impregnating force in the Annunciation. The motif of soul birds is well attested in early Christian literature and iconography. The soul becomes a dove at baptism; it identifies thereby with the Holy Spirit, the dove of Jesus’ baptism. As a dove, the soul of the departed becomes immortal, soaring up to heaven at death, especially at martyrdom.

   The eagle as a Christian symbol is bound up with a complex of ideas and images. For early Christians the eagle was symbolic of John the Evangelist because at the beginning of his gospel it is implied that John has risen to the heights of the genealogy of the Logos. But the eagle also symbolizes Jesus Christ himself, and it is believed that as an eagle Christ has accompanied John on his flight in quest of visions. Moreover, the eagle represents the Logos itself, just as in Judaism it signifies God or his power. Finally, the eagle depicted on Christian sarcophagi is inseparably associated with the hope for eternal life, light, and resurrection; it serves as the escort of the souls of departed Christians into immortal life with God.

   In Islamic literature and folklore, the symbolism of birds abounds. Farid al-Din ‘Attar’s famous epic Mantiq al-tayr (Conversation of the birds) uses the imagery of birds as human souls that journey through the seven valleys and, at the end of the road, discover their identity with the Simurgh, the divine bird that “has a name but no body,” a perfectly spiritual being. The Turkish saying “Can ku¸su uçtu” (“His soul bird has flown away”), uttered when someone dies, expresses the same concept. And throughout Persian and Persianate poetry and literature, one finds repeatedly the image of the nightingale (bulbul) in love with the radiant rose (gul), representing the soul longing for divine beauty. Birds are not yet deprived of symbolic meanings.

   Dreams of flying birds still haunt us. In his masterpiece Demian, Hermann Hesse has given new life to bird symbolism when he speaks of the “bird struggling out of the egg.” Modern man’s aspiration for freedom and transcendence has also been admirably expressed by the sculptor Constantin Brancusi through images of birds.

BIBLIOGRAPHY

The supreme importance of ornithomorphic symbolism and shamanism in the religious life of Paleolithic hunters has been stressed by Horst Kirchner in his article “Ein archäologischer

Beitrag zur Urgeschichte des Schamanismus,” Anthropos 47 (1952): 244–286. On the shaman’s ecstasy and his transformation into a bird, there is much useful material in Mircea Eliade’s Shamanism: Archaic Techniques of Ecstasy (New York, 1964). The bird type of the shamanic costume is illustrated in two works by Uno Harva (formerly Holmberg): The Mythology of All Races, vol. 4, Finno-Ugric, Siberian (Boston, 1927), and Die religiosen Vorstellungen der altaischen Volker (Helsinki, 1938). On the cosmogonic myths of the earth-diver type in which birds play a prominent role, see Mircea Eliade’s “The Devil and God,” in his Zalmoxis, the Vanishing God: Comparative Studies in the Religions and Folklore of Dacia and Eastern Europe (Chicago, 1972), pp. 76–130. On birds and kingship in Inner Asia and North Asia, see my article “Birds in the Mythology of Sacred Kingship,” East and West, n.s. 28 (1978): 283–289. The symbolism of birds in Judaism has been admirably studied by Erwin R. Goodenough in Pagan Symbols in Judaism (New York, 1958), volume 8 of his Jewish Symbols in the Greco-Roman Period. The best single book by a folklorist on folk beliefs and customs concerning birds is Edward A. Armstrong’s The Folklore of Birds: An Enquiry into the Origin and Distribution of Some Magico-Religious Traditions, 2d ed., rev. & enl. (New York, 1970).

New Sources

Estela Núñez, Carmen. “Asai, a Mythic Personage of the Ayoreo.” Latin American Indian Literatures 5 (Fall 1981): 64–67.

Luxton, Richard N. “Language of the Birds: Tales, Texts and Poems of the Interspecies Communication.” Latin American Indian Literatures Journal 3, no. 1 (Spring 1987): 61–62.

Seligmann, Linda J. “The Chicken in Andean History and Myth: The Quechua Concept of Wallpa.” Ethnohistory 34 (Spring 1987): 139–170.

Waida, Manabu. “Problems of Central Asian and Siberian Shamanism.” Numen 30 (December 1983): 215–239.

MANABU WAIDA (1987)

FROM: Manabu Waida, Birds, Encyclopaedia of Religion, Vol. 2, Second Edition, 1987, pp. 946 - 948

IMAGE: The Concourse of the Birds, Folio 11r from  Mantiq al-tair (Language_of_the_Birds)

 

Sunday, February 6, 2022

DISCOVERY OF THE MIND

R. B. Onians, The Origins of European Thought: About the Body, the Mind, the Soul, the World, Time and Fate, Cambridge University Press, 1954.

Marie-Louise von Franz: 

"Then there is a book in which you will find a tremendous amount of valuable material. It is by R.B. Onians and entitled The Origins of European Thought about the body, the mind, the soul, the world, time and fate (Cambridge, 1952). I urge anyone who intends to become an analyst to get that book. Under this funny title any amount of material has been collected on spittle, hair, sneezing, coughing, getting drunk by wetting your lungs, the diaphragm and all its mythological material. Onians is a classical scholar, but he has brought in primitive and comparative religious material, and you can look up every part of the body, as well as the involuntary human actions, such as scratching your belly, and what they mean. The origins of European thought have a strange background! The book has an excellent index, and you will find a lot that you will be able to use in dream interpretation." 

Marie-Louise von Franz, An Introduction to the Psychology of Fairy Tales, Spring Publications, 1975.

Samten:
Though this book is called Origins of European Thought, the material presented is universal, and purely archetypal in content. On a deeper level, when Onians introduces Sanskrit terms, we could say that the more complex strata of his material reveals the origins of Indo-European thought, or even PIE, Pre-Indo-European. Unfortunately, much of the material is inaccessible to readers who do not have a working knowledge of classical Greek, as Onians leaves all the terminology under examination in Greek. Nevertheless, one can work around this obstacle, and still gain some valuable insights.


Bruno Snell, The Discovery of the Mind. The Greek Origins of European Thought, Angelico Press, 2013.

"An illuminating and convincing account of the enormous change in the whole conception of morals and human personality which took place during the centuries covered by Homer, the early lyric poets, the dramatists, and Socrates." — The Times (London) Literary Supplement.

European thinking began with the Greeks. Science, literature, ethics, philosophy — all had their roots in the extraordinary civilization that graced the shores of the Mediterranean a few millennia ago. The rise of thinking among the Greeks was nothing less than a revolution; they did not simply map out new areas for thought and discussion, they literally created the idea of man as an intellectual being — an unprecedented concept that decisively influenced the subsequent evolution of European thought.
In this immensely erudite book, German classicist Bruno Snell traces the establishment of a rational view of the nature of man as evidenced in the literature of the Greeks — in the creations of epic and lyric poetry, and in the drama. Here are the crucial stages in the intellectual evolution of the Greek world: the Homeric world view, the rise of the individual in the early Greek lyric, myth and reality in Greek tragedy, Greek ethics, the origin of scientific thought, and Arcadia.

Drawing extensively on the works of Homer, Pindar, Archilochus, Aristophanes, Sappho, Heraclitus, the Greek tragedians, Parmenides, Callimachus, and a host of other writers and thinkers, Snell shows how the Homeric myths provided a blueprint for the intellectual structure the Greeks erected; how the notion of universality in Greek tragedy broadened into philosophical generalization; how the gradual unfolding of the concepts of intellect and soul provided the foundation for philosophy, science, ethics, and finally, religion.

Unquestionably one of the monuments of the Geistegeschichte (History of Ideas) tradition, The Discovery of the Mind throws fresh light on many long-standing problems and has had a wide influence on scholars of the Greek intellectual tradition. Closely reasoned, replete with illuminating insight, the book epitomizes the best in German classical scholarship — a brilliant exploration of the archetypes of Western thought; a penetrating explanation of how we came to think the way we do.

https://www.amazon.com/Discovery-Mind-Bruno-Snell/dp/0486242641

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bruno_Snell

 


Sunday, January 9, 2022

ANTOINE FAIVRE

As Favire recently passed away [December 20210], I have collected what I can,  books by him, related reviews  &c. I wrote to him in about 1986 – and he very kindly answered.  His name appears in the Ernst Hakl, Eranos book – I will extract the references as well,  in context. Material available on JSTOR. Samten de Wet..

Richard Smoley & Jay Kinney, What is Esotericism, The Gnosis Interview with Antoine Faivre, Gnosis Magazine, Number 31, Spring 1994.

Antoine Faivre and Karen-Claire Voss, Western Esotericism and the Science of Religions, Numen, Vol. 42, Fasc. 1 (Jan. 1995), pp. 48-77

Antoine Faivre, Access to Western Esotericism, SUNY Series in Western Esoteric Traditions, State University of New York Press, 1994

Description:

This is the first systematic treatment of esotericism to appear in English. Here is also a historical survey, beginning with the Alexandrean Period, of the various esoteric currents such as Christian Kabbalah, Theosophy, Alchemy, Rosicrucianism, and Hermeticism. Common characteristics of these currents are the notion of universal interdependency and the experience of spiritual transformation. The author establishes a rigorous methodology; provides clarifying definitions of such key terms as "gnosis," "theosophy," "occultism," and "Hermeticism;" and offers analysis of contemporary esotericism based on three distinct pathways. The second half of the book presents a series of studies on several important figures, works, and movements in Western esotericism--studies devoted to some of the most characteristic and illuminating aspects that this form of thought has taken, such as theosophical speculations on androgyny, rosicrucian literature, and Masonic symbolism. The book is completed by a rich and selective Bibliography conceived as a means of orientation and a tool for research.

Antoine Faivre, Christine Rhone, Western Esotericism: A Concise History, SUNY Series in Western Esoteric Traditions, State University of New York Press, 2010.

Description: An overview of Western esoteric currents since late antiquity, with an emphasis on the last six centuries.]


Antoine Faivre, Joscelyn Godwin, Eternal Hermes: From Greek God to Alchemical Magus, Phanes Press, 1995

Esoteric traditions are, well, esoterically complex as a rule, and that goes especially for Hermes Trismegistus, the emblematic figure representing--even personifying--the Western Esoteric tradition in its long and convoluted history. Who is he? Good question. Perhaps he's indeed a highly complex amalgam of the Egyptian god Thoth, the classical gods Hermes and Mercury, a priest in Alexandrian Egypt, and a legendary human sage roughly contemporary with Moses--among other things. God or man, angel or devil, master alchemist or proto-pharmacist, culture hero or trickster? Depends on who you ask. For anyone interested in this subject, then, it's all too easy to get lost without some guideposts of some sort.

And that's exactly what Antoine Faivre provides in "The Eternal Hermes" here. It's an excellently helpful overview, road-map, or starter kit, if you will. A collection of six separate articles, it gives the curious reader a good solid grasp of the general outlines of Hermes Trismegistus in a sympathetically objective scholarly tone. Chapter one, "Hermes in the Western Imagination" traces in as much detail as possible under the circumstances the varying influences contributing to Hermes' composite character and differing perceptions and characterizations of him throughout history from antiquity to the present. Chapter two, "The Children of Hermes and the Science of Man" attempts to define this figure's distinguishing orientations and spiritual traits (and of the movements which recognize him as their guardian and inspiration). Chapter Three, "From Hermes-Mercury to Hermes Trismegistus: The Confluence of Myth and the Mythical" focuses more on Hermes' slippery nature somewhere between deity and pseudo-historical personage, with obscure half-states in between.

Chapter four, "Hermes's Presence in the City" then remarkably demonstrates how the figure of Hermes, perhaps under other names but recognizable nonetheless, can be identified and analyzed in works of modern culture, both literature and film--in this case, Gustav Meyrink's novel "The Green Face", Luis Bunuel's film "Los Olvivados", and the sci-fi action movie "Mad Max Beyond Thunderdome". Places where one might not think to look at first, certainly. Chapter Five, "The Faces of Hermes Trismegistus" is a quick but illuminating survey of Hermes' iconography over time, as shown through 39 illustrations culled from any number of rare manuscripts and other cool sources. Finally Chapter Six, "The Inheritance of Alexandrian Hermetism: Historical and Bibliographical Landmarks" is perhaps the ultimate "further reading" list, lightly narrativized with commentary and infinitely helpful in creating order out of a chaos of sources.

Of course, if the book has one drawback, it's that, at under 200 pages, depth must be sacrificed to breadth. Faivre will often hint at what seem like mind-blowingly fascinating tales and legends only to seem pressed to move along without further ado. Furthermore, those for whom Hermeticism (or some related form of Western Esotericism) is a living spiritual path might find this book a bit dry and detached. Those coming at the subject with more academic and/or historical concerns in mind will be less distracted by this, naturally. Folks of either approach (and in-between) though will doubtlessly find this book to be enormously informative, and the manner in which it usefully lends a modicum of organization to what otherwise at first seems to be an impossibly confusing welter of stuff will facilitate further and deeper investigations according to one's own guiding lights.

Marco Pasi, Esotericism Emergent: The Beginning of the Study of Esotericism in the Academy. In A. D. DeConick (Ed.), Religion: Secret Religion, 2016, pp. 143-154. (Macmillan Interdisciplinary Handbooks). Macmillan. [HERE]

Nicholas Goodrick- Clarke, Aries, 10.2 (2010), pp.  272 - 301. [Book Reviews].

Nemanja Radulovic, Antoine Faivre and the Study of Fairy Tales, Aries, 14 (2014), pp. 190-214

Arthur McCalla, Antoine Faivre and the Study of Esotericism, Religion, (2001) 31, 435–450.  [Book Review]

David S. Katz, The Occult Tradition: From the Renaissance to the Present Day, Aries 9.2 (2009), pp. 263 - 295. [Book Review]


Antoine Faivre, "Access to Western Esotericism", p. 5:

"'Esotericism' conjures up chiefly the idea of something 'secret,' of a 'discipline of the arcane,' of restricted realms of knowledge....Certainly it is not a question here of considering the use of the word 'esotericism' illegitimate for secret, 'restricted' teachings. But we want only to note that it is not especially operative, because it is much too exclusive.  A large part of alchemy, for example, is not secret, when one considers the fact that since the sixteenth century, an abundant literature on alchemy has been continuously disseminated. The same is true of theosophy..... And when secrets do exist, they are generally open secrets.  The etymology of 'esotericism' clarifies the idea of secret by suggesting that we can access understanding of a symbol, myth, or reality only by a personal effort of progressive elucidation through several successive levels, i.e., by a form of hermeneutics. There is no ultimate secret once we determine that everything, in the end, conceals a secret..."

AND A DEFINITION:  [F esoterisme (1828), fr. LL adj. esotericus, fr. Gk adj. esoterikos, restricted knowledge or teaching (Aristotle)].

Tuesday, October 26, 2021

TAHAR BEN JELLOUN. AN UPHILL TASK

To make tolerance people's second nature is a duty that has to be done if the rule of law is to be established and consolidated. Without tolerance there is no democracy or, to put it another way, democracy and intolerance are irreconcilable opposites. Fanaticism is the fire surreptitiously lit by intolerance in the democratic fabric, it is a fixation, a deceptively pure-seeming obsession, an error that seeks to bring life anything that moves, changes and holds surprises to a standstill.

To tolerate fanaticism would be to tolerate the intolerable. How can fanaticism be allowed to monopolize the scene and make it a setting for tragedy? How is it possible to tolerate the enemies of freedom, those who would destroy intelligence and beauty, whose goal is a totalitarian order that imposes uniformity and proclaims that might is right, the law of the jungle? Where can one find the patience, courage and composure to refute this barbarity that prefers the use of the gun to that of the spoken or written word? How can one hold fast to one's principles, remain strictly respectful of beliefs different from, and even opposed to, one's own, and coexist with those who would wipe out anything that does not fit in with their crazed way of thinking?

Intolerance is only tolerable in art

Tolerance is an uphill task. It requires courage and strength, a robust aptitude for the cut and thrust of debate, and an ability to stand up to pressure. Who can claim to possess all these attributes? The answer is a combination of soldier and poet, policeman and philosopher, magistrate and artist for all great literature and all great painting have been the expression of intolerance of the intolerable. The writer's subject is not happiness, nor is peace that of the artist. Art is a clean break, a rejection, anger, provocation even. When beauty is laid waste, intelligence done to death, childhood violated and human beings humiliated, art cannot but be intolerant. It tolerates neither the ugliness of which people are capable nor the revulsion they arouse.

Fanaticism can be countered with humour; but this is sometimes a risky undertaking, since those who are fixated upon a certain order of things detest wit, subtlety and of course laughter. What they hold sacred is dogma, rigid and immutable. It is forbidden to make fun of it, whereas life, being short and beset with pitfalls, commends laughter as the best course. Laughter is often provocative, a way of distancing oneself a little from reality; but distance is something that has been totally banished from the world of intolerant people, who are so bound up in themselves they would like the rest of humanity to be identical clones of themselves.

Tolerance is something that has to be learned, a requirement that has to be lived with every day, a difficulty to be faced every moment of every day. It is hard work, but those who are attached to principles rather than prejudices or compromises do not seek the easy way out. They may not sleep soundly, it is true, but at least they do not relinquish that which makes us human, our dignity.

Tahar Ben Jelloun, An uphill task. The Unesco Courier, April 1995

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tahar_Ben_Jelloun

 

 

RUNNING AWAY

   Henry Miller:    "Everything we shut our eyes to, everything we run away from, everything we deny, denigrate, or despise, serves to ...